« Migrating between cloud providers made easy – StandingCloud | Makerbot Replicator 2 – unboxing and impressions »

Not all 4G is built equally

So you’ve no doubt taken the plunge and some device you own has been upgraded to 4G. Maybe it’s your new iPhone 5, maybe you’ve had a Galaxy Nexus since last year or maybe you just got a shinny new MiFi device. Either way how can you know that you’re getting the fastest bandwidth possible for your mobile needs? Well we’ve found that the actual device itself can mean almost as much as the network you’re using.

The chart below shows some simple testing I did with a number of 4G devices around our office. While this isn’t the most scientific test ever devised all the devices are on Verizon’s 4G LTE network. They were all in the same physical location, my desk in our office in downtown Boulder. All tests were done using Speedtest.net – again not the most scientific testing ever but something that would give us a real world idea of what to expect.


(each device ran 5 tests and these are the averages)

The results are fairly interesting. You’ll see the clear winner, as much as those who know me know I hate to admit this – the iPhone 5. While it’s up speeds weren’t the fastest they were rather consistent and it easily was the fastest for downloads (spiking to 22MB on occasion). While I’ve seen my Galaxy Nexus hit 45MB (in Las Vegas at CES last year) I haven’t gotten anywhere near that speed here in Boulder.

The chart also shows another clear thing – the dedicated MiFi devices are consistently slower than their multi-function brothers (even bested by an iPad 3). What did we learn from all this testing – it’s time to ditch our MiFi’s and live in an iPhone/iPad world for tethering. Not only is it a less expensive option it’s clearly the faster one – at least if your travels include my desk.

October 8th, 2012     Categories: Android, Apple, Reviews    
  • http://twitter.com/HKoren Henry Koren

    It would be interesting to see the standard deviations of the devices in addition to the averages.
    We are running our office off a ZTE in lieu of a 90 day fiber install. The orientation and height can have a HUGE affect on bandwidth. For my office near Foothills & Valmont, the optimum antenna location is 6 foot above ground upright and facing south. Thanks for the post!

    • rosscarlson

      Agreed Henry, honestly I deleted the little spreadsheet after I made the graph as I knew going in my data/testing wasn’t scientific at all. One of our partners was seeing this sort of real-world data and so I did the simple testing to see if it backed it up – and for the most part it did.

      And I succeeded in my goal – cancelling our remaining MiFis and saving us some money.

  • http://blog.hegranes.com/ jonathan hegranes

    I use a Samsung S3, and anecdotally have found my speeds to be much higher… The testing I’ve done is based not on my device, but rather which city I’m in.

    Dallas has registered the fasted speeds, with ~25 down / ~20 up.

    NYC is a close second… usually get close to 20 down / 10 up. SF is close to this as well.

    Regardless of specific devices or speeds, totally agree that this is becoming a tethering world. My LTE connection is faster than our office, and is a life saver for meetings or simply being out of the office.

    Was recently in Toronto and they can freely tether with an iPhone… I hope that functionality is coming closer to a standard feature, than something I need to pay an extra $50 or so (just to be able to access the data I’m already paying for).

  • http://twitter.com/MatEllis Mat Ellis

    I’ve been measuring my iPad3 Verizon LTE speeds since I got it, and have regularly spiked over 30 megabits. I’m not surprised to see the iPhone5 best it in tests and look forward to doing like for like comparisons when I get mine.

  • Pingback: Not all 4G is built equally | Jasbone’s Thoughts | Itsaat

  • http://twitter.com/jeffchow_ Jeff Chow

    I’m in South Boulder and was testing tethering speeds of my iPhone 5 on Verizon and am not getting anything close to that. Just now: 1.67 Mbps down, 0.03 Mbps up. Yesterday I averaged 7 down and 0.5 up. Was hoping to use it for a emergency webcast near 28th and Pearl. Think I’d have more luck up there?